Asked if his success helped with the ladies, Bateman uncomfortably responded, “It’s advantageous to initially meet the girl, but I don’t really want to go out with a girl, you know, because she likes me because I’m an actor or something like that. You know, I want her to go out with me because she likes me as a person.” Carson asked, “Do they use the term going steady anymore?” “That’s back — like, about 10 years ago they used the term going steady,” Bateman replied. To which Carson quipped, “My mail has been slow.”

But Bateman’s incredibly mature answers weren’t the point of showing the clip, the point was the sweatshirt he was wearing. Kimmel quickly pulled out a promotional ad for Bateman’s short-lived sitcom It’s Your Move, and a picture of Bateman from Bop magazine. In both instances, Bateman is wearing the exact same sweatshirt he wore on The Tonight Show.

Upon seeing this, Bateman said, “Guess who had a favorite sweatshirt.” Kimmel followed with, “Guess who’s got another one.”

Kimmel then pulled out an adult-size version of the same sweatshirt, which Bateman immediately put on, then posed. But being the showbiz vet that he is, upon sitting back down, Bateman held his suit jacket up to his shoulder so he could still be close to the microphone that was clipped on it, and he was quick to point out how awkward it was.

“God, I hope people are just tuning in right now,” Bateman joked. Kimmel added, “It looks like your puppet died.”

Jimmy Kimmel Live airs weeknights at 11:35 p.m. on ABC.

Watch Dionne Warwick discuss the huge error on the French version of her album: ‘I ain’t no white woman’: